Scott and Sadie
Home » Phish Wins Rock Hall Fan Vote—Now What?

Phish Wins Rock Hall Fan Vote—Now What?

Phish tops the 2024 Rock Hall fan vote! But will it matter? Here’s who else ranked high—and why winning doesn’t guarantee induction.

Results of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame fan vote are in, and the winner is . . . Phish, with 330,000 votes.

Bad Company came in second with 281,000, followed by Billy Idol with 260,500. 

Cyndi Lauper finished fourth with 237,000, and Joe Cocker rounds out the Top 5 with 234,000.  The rest of the Top 10, in this order, is SoundgardenChubby Checker, the Black CrowesMariah Carey, and Joy DivisionNew Order.

The fan vote doesn’t have a ton of influence on who makes the Hall. 

It only counts for a SINGLE BALLOT, among roughly 1,200 that are cast.  But there’s only one year when the winner of the fan vote didn’t make the Hall:  It was the Dave Matthews Band in 2020.  But they got in four years later.

This year’s inductees will be announced this Sunday night on “American Idol”.

Scott and Sadie

Meet Scott and Sadie: the anti-heroes of morning radio turned podcast renegades. Scott’s 40 years in broadcasting have left him fluent in snark, while Sadie’s nepotistic origins (thanks, Mom!) brought the unfiltered charm that made them a Northern Colorado favorite. After corporate radio ghosted them harder than a bad Tinder date, the duo ditched FCC babysitters and went full rogue. Now, they’re back with a podcast that’s equal parts wit, sarcasm, and a big middle finger to mediocrity. Loyal fans, curious newcomers, or algorithm strays—welcome to the chaos.

Let us into your inbox!

Follow us

Social media: the digital dumpster fire where your aunt’s conspiracy theories meet your cousin’s MLM pitches, and everyone’s a keyboard warrior with the IQ of a houseplant. It’s a wretched hive of scum, villainy, and thirst traps—but hey, we’re there too! So, come swim with us in the muck and give us a follow. At least our nonsense is funny on purpose.

Let us into your inbox!