Scott and Sadie
Home » The Best Girl Scout Cookies, Ranked! 🍪

The Best Girl Scout Cookies, Ranked! 🍪

Happy 113th birthday, Girl Scouts! 🎉 They’ve been selling cookies since 1917—so which one is the best? A baker ranked them all! 🍪

Happy 113th birthday to the Girl Scouts!  They were founded on March 12th, 1912, then the first Girl Scout cookie was sold five years later in 1917.  So, what’s YOUR favorite? 

The site “Taste of Home” had a professional baker rank them.  See if you agree . . .

1.  Thin Mints.  It’s still their best-selling cookie.

2.  Samoas . . . called Caramel deLites in some areas.

3.  Tagalongs . . . a.k.a., Peanut Butter Patties

4.  Toast-Yays.  They debuted in 2021, but they’re being discontinued next year.  Wikipedia lists 66 cookies that have been discontinued over the years.

5.  Lemonades

6.  S’mores.  They’re also being discontinued after this year.

7.  Do-Si-Dos . . . a.k.a., Peanut Butter Sandwiches

8.  Toffee-tastics

9.  Trefoils . . . a.k.a. Shortbread cookies

10.  Adventurefuls

11.  Caramel Chocolate Chip.

There’s also one called Lemon-Ups, but “Taste of Home” didn’t include it in the rankings.  (???)  So . . . I guess that’s last place? 

(Taste of Home)

Scott and Sadie

Meet Scott and Sadie: the anti-heroes of morning radio turned podcast renegades. Scott’s 40 years in broadcasting have left him fluent in snark, while Sadie’s nepotistic origins (thanks, Mom!) brought the unfiltered charm that made them a Northern Colorado favorite. After corporate radio ghosted them harder than a bad Tinder date, the duo ditched FCC babysitters and went full rogue. Now, they’re back with a podcast that’s equal parts wit, sarcasm, and a big middle finger to mediocrity. Loyal fans, curious newcomers, or algorithm strays—welcome to the chaos.

Let us into your inbox!

Follow us

Social media: the digital dumpster fire where your aunt’s conspiracy theories meet your cousin’s MLM pitches, and everyone’s a keyboard warrior with the IQ of a houseplant. It’s a wretched hive of scum, villainy, and thirst traps—but hey, we’re there too! So, come swim with us in the muck and give us a follow. At least our nonsense is funny on purpose.

Let us into your inbox!