Scott and Sadie
Home » Thanksgiving Leftovers: Feast or Food Poisoning? Know When to Let Go

Thanksgiving Leftovers: Feast or Food Poisoning? Know When to Let Go

Wondering how long you can safely indulge in Thanksgiving leftovers? Learn the crucial timelines to prevent turning your holiday feast into a foodborne fiasco.

Thanksgiving—the annual festival where we express gratitude by stuffing ourselves senseless, only to face the inevitable aftermath: a fridge bursting with leftovers. But before you dive into that week-old stuffing, let’s tackle the burning question: When should you finally part ways with those holiday remnants?

The Two-Hour Rule: Because Bacteria Don’t Take Holidays

First off, if you let your turkey lounge on the counter for more than two hours, congratulations—you’ve created a bacterial playground. Perishable foods left out for over two hours enter the “Danger Zone” (40°F to 140°F), where bacteria multiply faster than holiday credit card debt. So, unless you’re aiming for a side of food poisoning, get those leftovers into the fridge pronto.

Refrigeration: Your Leftovers’ Temporary Safe Haven

Once safely refrigerated, you’ve got a three to four-day window to enjoy your leftovers. That means by the time Monday rolls around, it’s decision time: eat it, freeze it, or toss it. Ignoring this timeline is like playing Russian roulette with your digestive system.

Freezing: The Procrastinator’s Best Friend

If you’re not ready to part with Aunt Marge’s green bean casserole, freezing is your go-to move. Properly stored, frozen leftovers maintain their quality for two to six months. But remember, “frozen” doesn’t mean “immortal.” After a while, even your freezer won’t save that sad slice of pumpkin pie.

Reheating: Nuke It Right or Pay the Price

When it’s time to reheat, aim for an internal temperature of 165°F. Use a food thermometer, not your finger, to check. And if you’re microwaving, stir the food to avoid cold spots where bacteria can lurk. Half-hearted reheating is a surefire way to turn your meal into a bacterial buffet.

Signs Your Leftovers Have Turned Against You

If your leftovers emit a funky odor, sport a questionable texture, or have changed colors, it’s time to bid them farewell. No meal is worth a trip to the ER. When in doubt, throw it out.

The Bottom Line: Set a Deadline

To keep your post-Thanksgiving feasting safe, remember: refrigerate within two hours, consume within four days, and reheat to 165°F. Your stomach will thank you, and you’ll avoid spending Cyber Monday hugging the toilet.

(Food Safety USDA)

Scott and Sadie

Meet Scott and Sadie: the anti-heroes of morning radio turned podcast renegades. Scott’s 40 years in broadcasting have left him fluent in snark, while Sadie’s nepotistic origins (thanks, Mom!) brought the unfiltered charm that made them a Northern Colorado favorite. After corporate radio ghosted them harder than a bad Tinder date, the duo ditched FCC babysitters and went full rogue. Now, they’re back with a podcast that’s equal parts wit, sarcasm, and a big middle finger to mediocrity. Loyal fans, curious newcomers, or algorithm strays—welcome to the chaos.

Let us into your inbox!

Spam is delicious when diced and scrambled with eggs and cheese. Spam sucks when it's in your email. We promise never to spam you or sell your info - we'll just send you a daily email about our latest podcast and the stuff on our site.
* = required field

Follow us

Social media: the digital dumpster fire where your aunt’s conspiracy theories meet your cousin’s MLM pitches, and everyone’s a keyboard warrior with the IQ of a houseplant. It’s a wretched hive of scum, villainy, and thirst traps—but hey, we’re there too! So, come swim with us in the muck and give us a follow. At least our nonsense is funny on purpose.

Let us into your inbox!

Spam is delicious when diced and scrambled with eggs and cheese. Spam sucks when it's in your email. We promise never to spam you or sell your info - we'll just send you a daily email about our latest podcast and the stuff on our site.
* = required field